Mad Love, and Mr. Sunshine. Unfortunately the shows have already been cancelled, but they are still definitely worth the watch.
Mad Love features among others Jason Biggs, but no pies. Mad Love is basically How I Met Your Mother, only he meets the girl in the first episode. To really drive home the similarity, the girl is played by Sarah Chalke. I always liked Tyler Labine in Reaper, and this character isn't much different from Bert "Sock" Wysocki.
Mr. Sunshine features Matthew Perry as Ben Donovan, the operations manager in the Sunshine Center, an arena in San Diego. The big star in this show is Ben's boss Crystal Cohen, played by Allison Janney. She and Matthew Perry really makes this a fun show. The show is co-created by Matthew Perry.
You can watch Mr. Sunshine here.